Imagine a country where there are people of different ethnicities and faiths, living together and trying to live a peaceful life, then you see their soft media releasing films that can harm a certain group of people that have a different faith from the majority, and those films can also ignite and help make a presumption about that specific faith believers, and to make the situation much worse, the government of that country starts to support the filmmakers of those films.
BY IBRAHIM MUNIR
The
same situation is happening in India where the sentiments are ignited
by some of the filmmakers getting support from the BJP
government. The main aim of these
filmmakers is spreading hatred towards minority groups which can contribute to
the further marginalization of vulnerable communities by using propaganda
techniques like “The
Big Lie”; a propaganda strategy that Adolf Hitler used, that Mein Kampf originates says “The
great masses of the people… will more easily fall victim to a big lie than to a
small one” and “Repeat a lie often enough and it becomes the truth” that
is also attributed to Nazi Government. One of the examples is the recent film “The
Kerala Story”.
This
film was directed by Sudipto Sen, that flamed a storm of controversy, painting
a disturbing hate picture of Kerala as a place of forced conversions and
objectifying women by showing women a channel to ISIS. “The Big Lie” of this
propaganda film was its central claim that 32000 women were converted to Islam
and trafficked to ISIS, which got into widespread
criticism. After the film got legal
notices, the director admitted that this
number was an "exaggeration," reducing the exaggerated number to
"3". While the experiences of these three women are undoubtedly
significant, framing them as part of a mass conspiracy is not only fraudulent
but deeply irresponsible.
The
film’s narrative ignores the ground reality of radicalization in India, rapidly spreading among
the public. The official report claims that only 66 individuals joined ISIS from
India, with only 3
women from Kerala exposing the big lie
propaganda technique of this film. Contrary to this, countries like the UK, France, and Germany, with significantly smaller Muslim populations, have witnessed far
more numbers of individuals joining
extremist groups like ISIS. This explicit difference completely exposes the
film's true agenda: to demonize and propagandize an entire state and its Muslim
community based on a handful of cases.
The film also presents the dangerous myth of ‘Love Jihad’, a conspiracy theory that claims there is a systematic procedure to convert non-Muslim women through marriage. This propaganda not only portrays Muslim men but also exploits women, portraying them as rag dolls. Multiple investigations, including by the National Investigation Agency (NIA), have disproved the existence of such organized work. The film's success seems to be based on its use of fear and self-doubt. By including a few cases and framing them as a conspiracy theory, it attempts to launch a campaign against certain governments and Muslim minorities.
This trick is unfortunately
understood by a group of people who like to believe the worst about '” others”. The
controversy surrounding "The Kerala Story" is not just about a single
film; it is a reflection of a broader trend of political polarization and the
weaponization of media narratives, using Bollywood to spread hatred and
propaganda for political gain. We can see movies like Kashmir Files, Mission
Majnu, Ek tha Tiger, and Article 370 that are intoxicated with propaganda. BJP following
the footsteps of Hiter’s Rule in a country as diverse as India is a dangerous
fire to play with.
Filmmakers
have a responsibility to ensure that their work is based on truth and does not
contribute to the continued exclusion of underprivileged communities. Likewise,
the public of India and Indian media have a responsibility to examine such stories
and separate facts from propaganda. Ultimately, the debate on the “Kerala story”
highlights the need for a more inclusive discussion on religion, identity, and
social relations. A society that celebrates diversity and rejects the politics
of fear and division can only be built through open and honest dialogue based
on compassion and commitment to truth.
The writer is a student at National Defense
University, Islamabad, and is currently serving as an intern at the Kashmir
Institute of International Relations